February 2, 2019
When is it appropriate to forgive someone? Should a person be branded for a lifetime for youthful mistakes?
These are a couple of the questions that have occurred to me over the last two days as I’ve read about a current political controversy. Virginia Governor Ralph Northam is being pressured to resign after admitting to one and possibly two incidents of appearing in blackface in 1984, when he was about 25 years old. One occasion happened at a dance contest, and another was a photo in his medical school yearbook.
Governor Northam has apologized for the offensive events. Should he resign? I don’t know, but he will almost certainly have to do so. Yet an important question needs to be asked: Has he changed his racial insensitivity in the last 35 years? By all accounts a progressive Democrat on civil rights matters, he has indeed changed. But in the current political climate, it may not matter.
If the governor had committed these acts a year ago, or even five years ago, I would say that he has to go. But 35 years ago? Can we realistically expect politicians, and each other, to be so perfect all of the time? Are we not allowed to outgrow our youthful indiscretions, or even our mature adult mistakes?
It’s not my place to forgive Northam. I’ll leave that for African Americans to decide, as they are the ones who would have felt any pain from his blackface stereotypes.
I myself am not always so forgiving. I have held my share of grudges, although I do seem to let them go eventually. One reason I try to forgive others is that I’m painfully aware of my own insensitivities to others on occasion (see my January 24 blog post about Barbara). Another reason is that I simply feel better when I let go of anger, bitterness, or resentment. I don’t know whether I’d be able to forgive someone who murdered a family member or close friend. I hope so, but I just don’t know, and I hope I never have to find out.
When I was in high school I was bullied my entire sophomore year by Bob, a guy who was a year older and bigger than me. He abused me physically, psychologically, and emotionally. I hated him, and fantasized about killing him. I even thought about bringing a knife to school to stab him (this was well before anyone thought of bringing guns to school). I never told anyone about the abuse, but I never forgot it either. Many years later I decided to forgive him. I reasoned that he was 16 at the time, and just a stupid kid, so I should let go of my hate and heal myself and move on.
Then, at my 45th high school reunion, Bob showed up. He wasn’t in our class, but came because he had friends who were. I debated whether or not to speak to him, let alone confront him about his past misdeeds. What if he got defensive, or continued with his past ridicule of me? Would I get angry and bitter all over again? Would this just reopen old wounds?
I decided to face my past. I asked him if we could speak privately. Then I calmly reminded him of what had transpired between us 45 years ago. To my surprise and disappointment, he didn’t remember a school year’s worth of bullying! But to his credit, he listened carefully, and then apologized profusely and sincerely for having been such a jerk. I told him that I had forgiven him long ago, but even so it was healing to hear him take responsibility for all the suffering he had caused me. And it was healing for me to risk an ugly encounter in order to stand up for my 15 year old self.
I don’t believe that there is always justice in a given lifetime. But I do believe that, over many lifetimes, what goes around comes around. And if I can practice forgiveness now, maybe I can earn the right to be forgiven for my transgressions. Even if others don’t forgive me, maybe I can learn to forgive myself.